Board Thread:Contests and Competitions/@comment-29331244-20150513231444/@comment-29331244-20150515024843

If the fifth man is a police:

The fourth man (might be a civilian or thief) is lying. If the fourth man is lying, the first one must be a civilian.

Referring to third man whom say: I'm a thief. Since the police would never lie and a thief never stated honestly that he is a thief. The third man is a civilian.

Talking back to fourth man, the first and third man is civilian so the fourth man must be a thief. (There's only 2 civilians at the first). Second man say: I'm not civilian. The thief wouldn't be honest, so the second is a police.

Polices are Second/Fifth man (1.5 point to Tariq Jabbar and Balu.ur) Civilians are First/Third man (1.5 point to Balu.ur) Thief is Fourth man (No-one get the point :1)

There's still many other possibilities though. Good jobs to Tariq and Balu.ur :1